I Was Stumped When Asked About My Research Question

PhD students are often faced with a defining moment early in their journey: being asked, “What is your research question?” For many, this question creates confusion or anxiety, especially if they haven’t yet refined their research focus. Do not worry because identifying a strong, clear research question is a process—and like all processes it takes time, structure, and iteration.

This guide provides a structured approach to help PhD students address this challenge, drawing on expert advice, research strategies, and actionable steps from Chanakya Research where experts in academic consulting provide personalized guidance for your research field and interests. Whether you need help identifying research gaps, brainstorming potential questions, or refining a draft, their expertise has been the difference for many students. So if you do feel stuck or overwhelmed towards the end of the blog - give our research consultant a try! .

Why a Research Question Matters

A research question is one of the foundational aspects of a successful PhD journey. It provides direction, purpose, and a framework for your study. Without it, research can become unfocused or overly broad. Here’s why defining your research question is crucial:

It narrows down the vast possibilities in your field to a specific, manageable topic.
A clear question acts as a roadmap, ensuring all your efforts align with your objectives.
It highlights the unique aspect of your research and how it fills a gap in the field.
A focused question ensures you don’t waste time exploring tangents.

Step 1: Start Broad—Exploring Your Interests

Defining a research question begins with identifying areas that excite you. Passion for your topic sustains motivation during the inevitable challenges of a PhD.

How to Identify Your Interests:

Review Your Background Reflect on prior academic work or professional experiences that you enjoyed.
Explore Emerging Trends Skim recent journals, conferences, or articles in your field to identify hot topics.
Talk to Experts Engage with supervisors or expert consultants from Chanakya Research for example to gain insights into pressing research gaps.

Tips for Narrowing Focus:

Break a large field into subfields and consider where your curiosity lies.
Jot down broad questions you have about your field and prioritize the ones that feel most compelling.

Step 2: Conduct a Literature Review

A thorough literature review is essential to understanding the current state of knowledge in your field. It helps you identify what’s already been done and where there are gaps that need to be addressed.

Key Steps in a Literature Review:

Collect Sources: Use databases like Google Scholar, PubMed, or Scopus to find relevant articles and books.
Categorize Information: Organize studies by themes, methodologies, or findings to spot patterns.
Identify Gaps: Look for areas that are underexplored, contradictory, or outdated.

Tools and Techniques:

Use software like Zotero or EndNote for citation management.
Create a visual mind map to connect ideas and identify potential gaps.

Step 3: Brainstorm and Refine

Once you’ve identified a broad area and gaps in the literature, it’s time to brainstorm possible research questions.

Techniques for Generating Ideas:

Mind Mapping Write down your central topic and branch out related subtopics, questions, and keywords.
Question Frameworks Use models like the FINERMAPS criteria (Feasible, Interesting, Novel, Ethical, Relevant, etc.) to evaluate the viability of your ideas.

Questions to Reflect On:

What problem am I addressing?
Why is this problem important?
What impact will solving this problem have on my field or society?

Refining Your Question:

Start with a general question and refine it by adding specificity.
1. ExampleBroad: “What impacts climate change?” Refined: “How do urban heat islands influence local microclimates in mid-sized cities?”
Use SMART criteria (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) to evaluate clarity and feasibility.

Step 4: Seek Feedback and Collaborate

Collaboration and feedback are invaluable when defining your research question. Fresh perspectives can highlight potential blind spots or refine your focus.

Who to Consult:

Supervisors/AdvisorsThey bring expertise and can guide you to relevant resources or suggest adjustments.
PeersFellow students may offer fresh perspectives or share their own experiences.
Experts in the FieldReach out to researchers or attend academic conferences like Research Camps organized by Chanakya Research to discuss your ideas.

How to Present Your Ideas: Prepare a concise summary of your research interests and potential questions.

Step 5: Evaluate and Test Your Question

Before committing to a research question, ensure it meets academic and practical standards. Use the following checklist:

Checklist for a Good Research Question:

Clarity: Is the question easy to understand and free from ambiguity?
Relevance: Does it address a significant problem in the field?
Feasibility: Can you realistically address it within your timeline and resources?
Novelty: Does it offer new insights or perspectives?

Examples of Weak vs. Strong Questions:

Weak: “What are the effects of technology?” (Too broad and vague.)
Strong: “How does the use of augmented reality in education improve student engagement in middle school classrooms?” (Specific, measurable, and relevant.)

Overcoming Common Challenges

Defining a research question isn’t without its hurdles. Here’s how to tackle some common challenges:

Feeling Overwhelmed by Options:
1. Focus on one area at a time and start small.
2. Remember, it’s okay to refine or change your question as you progress.
Fear of Picking the “Wrong” Question:
1. No question is perfect; the process of refining and answering it is what matters.
Limited Understanding of the Field:
1. Spend more time reading and engaging with the literature.
2. Attend workshops or seminars to deepen your understanding.

Staying Motivated Throughout the Process

Defining a research question can feel daunting, but persistence and patience are key. Remember:

It’s normal to feel unsure at the start.
The process of developing a question is iterative; it will evolve as your knowledge deepens.
Each small step—whether reading a paper, writing down an idea, or discussing with a mentor—brings you closer to clarity.

Being asked about your research question can be intimidating, especially if you’re still finding your footing. The truth is, defining your research question is not a one-time task but an evolving process that requires a deep understanding of your field. A crucial step in this journey is conducting a thorough literature review to identify and resolve gaps in existing research, which directly informs the development of your research question. If you’re ready to dive deeper into this process, check out our blog on ‘How to Identify and Resolve Literature Gaps from the Literature Review.’ It provides insights to help you through this critical phase with clarity so your research is both impactful and relevant.

Blog